Many viewers will say that a happy ending does not excuse a drama from obvious plot holes, but I'll give TWTWB a pass. help you understand the book. : Not all chemo causes you to loose your hair - my dad takes oral chemo and doesn't loose his. Hence, left all alone and surrounded by the vast open prairie, Lizzy begins cleaning up her blood-soaked kitchen. And if the case hasn't been resolved by June 30 . Really? Soo chaotic and rushed and nonsensical. Read instantly on your browser with Kindle for Web. But it could be Minions shady-lookin dude guarding them, which means its a good thing. The next day, upon Isaacs return, he mentions that he met the reverend on the way. Customer Reviews, including Product Star Ratings help customers to learn more about the product and decide whether it is the right product for them. Nor are the ladies & gentlemen of the castle as aristocratic as they believe they are. . With Emma, it was her annoying dependence, and with Isaac, it was the revelation that he had had an affair with Emma. Watching that drama made me want to be sure not to take any of my loved ones for granted, to look for the good in each person, and to sing Kumbaya (just kidding). The famed poet Henry Wadsworth Longfellow once penned the beautiful words, "Be still, sad heart! Acting was stellar too. Make Kim think Oh Soo, died like Moo Chul had everyone thinking he was threatening Soo instead of just warning him? var js, fjs = d.getElementsByTagName(s)[0]; She needed her since Soo was not in her daily life. Secretary Wang wants to know why, considering how she made Young, you know, blind. She hands it to Gideon, Emmas husband, who howls in sadness. However, by the time he returns, we cant even be completely sure if the Isaac that we are seeing is real or a figment of Lizzys haunted imagination. Boss Man is hosting the game, and announces the grand prize - seven million dollars. I dont understand why this conversation cant happen now. One thing I'm going to disagree with you on Heads is the sentiment of Young's suicide attempt being "merely" a cry for attention, because that's what all suicide attempts are. It can't be heaven either, because they would've just MET each other. I made the mistake to watch Frozen flower since everybody was talking about it. Similarly, in Goodbye Solo, NHK gradually gets you into the head and the heart of each character-- you may not like some of the characters or their actions, but you'll understand where they're coming from. If the ending wasn't real then that was s a very elaborate dream with the cafe, watress, the fact that Soo had been for 6 months. 4. Some of my questions might seem superficial, however I wish things had been made clear for us :-(. The trailer for No Way Home revealed a bit of how that will happen: Doctor Strange (Benedict Cumberbatch) will seemingly break the multiverse while trying to undo the moment when Peter Parker's. Really? Very pretty to look at like a picture, but barely engaging and forgettable in the end. Granted, some things started to not make sense towards the end, but NOTHING about this show makes me think the director or writer became lazy and gave up along the way. A flashback reveals that on the night she died, Emma and Lizzy met out in the prairie, where Emma revealed her intention to send Gideon away and live with Isaac, Lizzy, and the baby. The ending of Final Fantasy 7 Remake is unexpected, a little confusing, and very, very meta. They could have done the movie with only half of them. Anyway, I thought it was clear enough that the ending was real, the blurry perspective was Young's post-surgery sight as Kaye says. I'm sort of slack-jawed right now. Because she chatted and interacted with him. She tells him that she even got to eat with her mother the night before, though they had to hide the fact from her father. For bookclub, we had to choose a book with a time travel element in it. What the Wind Knows Summary & Study Guide Amy Harmon This Study Guide consists of approximately 65 pages of chapter summaries, quotes, character analysis, themes, and more - everything you need to sharpen your knowledge of What the Wind Knows. It was only in the last episode where the drama hinted at how he likes to cook. Im a huge fan of love me not - the movie, and for me, twtwb was the perfect adaptation, im sure no other producer could have made it better. Srsly the ending confused me i wanted to see wt happened next when Soo got staped i mean when he healed and stuff XD hmph oky i was happy that they ended together & happy ending but not like this lol . The ending seems to be pushed/could be better, yes. Hee-sun cries at the sight of Moo-chuls body in the morgue, while Jin-sung stays to comfort her. No payoff with Denna Ambrose The secret in the Archives his music career the Chandrian his university studies with Fella With sympathy or naming. Young wakes up to find Soo asleep at her bedside, and as she brushes her fingers across his face she remembers his desperate plea for her to watch his video. Anne is surprised to learn that Eoin wants her to spread his ashes in Ireland on Lough Gill. And I want to pay for what Ive done, he chokes out. , File size Without knowing exactly how she crossed into this time, she cannot promise she will remain. I did chuckle many times reading this recap. It's a really nice juxtaposition, imo. The vaunted cinematography of this drama may appear genuinely impressive at first, but it dawns upon you sooner or later that, however it wants to emulate it, this is not a Merchant-Ivory film. Anne Gallagher is in the home of her grandfather, Eoin Gallagher, in 2001 as he is dying. Is that really the type of mommy dearest love we are supposed to buy into? And if somehow the show fails to root a characters emotions and reactions in some form of universal logic, then in the words of Cool Hand Luke, What weve got here is a failure to communicate.. Which might be realistic. South Wind Knows My Mood Episode 38. His care for Anne shows the type of love every woman should aspire to find. I love you.. I really wanted to like this show, just like I wanted to like Young, and I find them both frustrating and prickly and immensely illogical. Secretary Wang and Young have a heart to heart as Wang tells her that even after the surgery, Young wont be able to live alone not because shes handicapped, but because no one can do anything alone. : Amy Harmon holds more talent in her little finger than most of us could wish to acquire in a lifetime. Nothing made sense in this ending, i dare say a couple more deaths would have made it more believable, Oh Soo included! Blog Home Uncategorized what the wind knows ending explained. Don't get me wrong I enjoyed the show but I just feel disappointed because it could have been a great drama. (I frowny-faced at that, honestly. He tightens the bell bracelet on his wrist in preparation, since its his life on the line. fjs.parentNode.insertBefore(js, fjs); You'll recognize delusion, jealousy, seduction, and shapeshifting as things Lizzy encounters during the movie. (Even Wang's redemption arc, though not something I agree with, was well supported within the story -- it didn't come out of nowhere.). And when Soo pulls back, they both look into each others eyes, smiling. And I know kdramas are all about redemption and forgiveness but pls not Secretary Wang, r u kidding me?! What's Up With the Ending? Try again. Through this drama my love for SHK is firm now and not much to JIS. While federal student loan payments are currently paused, that will end 60 days after the case is resolved. The cafe, the talking people, Soo dressed as a waiter. Maybe they are all waiting for Moo chul to show up. The average scores when I downloaded this book place it up with The Help and Eleanor Oliphant and that is very misleading imho. The plot is shrouded in mystery. It always took some time with him. My hope: This drama was a commissioned one and in exchange of this ratings success SBS will let her write her own personal project. I agree with you all the way! I had watched NG but do not remember how the drama ended but I will remember every details about TWTWB. I hate unreasonable story, because it messes my head. Like what were they trying to achieve with that effect? During the days by herself, Lizzy is chased by wolves and subsequently sees her dead sheep come back to life. As for Soo, I mean, dude got stabbed not shot. I don't care what others may feel about this drama, but from any dramas so far in 2013, this is the only drama that artistically the best, directed the best and acted the best. Really? , Page numbers source ISBN Does this item contain quality or formatting issues? Heartbroken at his death, she travels to his childhood home to spread his ashes. Directed by Charlie McDowell ( The One I Love ), with a screenplay from Andrew Kevin Walker and Justin Lader, Windfall stars Jason Segel as a nameless manquite literally credited as "Nobody"who. 5. Summary. My biggest gripe is the directing of this show. One of the main driving forces of Lizzys frustration is her solitude in suffering. Her books are now being published in two dozen languages, truly a dream come true for a little country girl. It is also in the mind of the person a VIABLE solution to their problem. this reminds me why I'm not a fan of the genre. When I first started watching More Beautiful Than a Flower, I didn't know that it was written by NHK. everything you need to sharpen your knowledge of What the Wind Knows. But after actually watching it, I'm 100% sure they're both alive. Did the CCTV goons end up getting him because his promise, in a sense, broke (to let Soo & Jin Sung go unscathed)? well probably what heads meant was that since she underwent a brain surgery, at least part of her hair had to be completely shaved prior to it being performed.. Now shes looking toward the future, to when theyll meet again. Also, Heads! "The Wind" tells its story through a non-linear narrative that begins with a pregnant Emma dying from a self-inflicted gunshot wound to the head. I sometimes miss some of those, and I appreciate when those are pointed out to me. She had been missing for days. Tied to her bed and with the shadowy entity looming high, Lizzy stabs Isaac when he tries to stop her from untying herself. I felt that the plot and the characterizations started to fall apart in the last episodes. This is one drama that defies logic. As the story jumps back and forth in time, we learn that leading up to her death, Emma's behavior had become increasingly erratic, while after her death, Lizzy has come to believe that she too is being menaced by the entity her neighbor claimed to hear whispering to her on the wind. Despite my love for the main three characters, the standout in my mind was Maeve. There are some other very real plot developments that will help to further interpret the film's ending. I think Jo In Sung really out did himself here and would watch it again. I have loved the history of Ireland for a long time and even visited the West Coast in Connemara last year to try and acquire a picture in my mind and heart of this magnificent country. - I really praised the writer for having this kind of story. Thank you for pointing out the many holes and for doing it with some humor at times. When he was taking MCW's character to sell her into sex slavery he was really taking her to sell into sex slavery. The most important thing being that Soo was still standing at the end-would have hated that he died Young was still alive. Hed told Wang not to tell Young. When Lizzy opens it, the camera lingers long enough to see the list of demons and their attributes. However, I really think her brain cancer would be treated with gamma knife radiation - had a friend's mother die from a brain tumor and they didn't treat with chemo but radiation. TWTWB, with its muted colors, its intensity 24/7 (made even more intense by all of the close-up shots), its one-dimensional side characters like batshit-crazy So Ra, its hard-to-read heroine, and its contrived plot full of holes, made TWTWB feel quite unreal which would've been fine had it come together as an inspired mythic tale. The surreal film follows a woman's slow descent into madness as she struggles to survive the crushing solitude of the 19th-century frontier lands. Young has a surprisingly full head of long hair a year after brain surgery, and everyone seems to be having a good time. or Any Way . Please enter your username or email address. The flowers of MS and JS was at the table. I was drawn to the cover first--it has to be one of the most beautiful I've ever seen--and then a snippet drew me in deeper. We also see things that may be influencing her perceptions, including witnessing Emma's emotional decline and Lizzy's interest in a pamphlet titled "Demons of the Prairie" (more on that later). I guess its up to intrepretation but it may be that those two are actually alive and everything went well OR they both diedSoo died first bc he got stabbed which is why he is at the restaurant "6 months before" waiting for her. Young not only forgives her, but understands that Wang loved her all this time and just couldnt express it properly. Does this item contain inappropriate content? They could be referring to the REAL Oh Soo. Oooh, a twist! And thanks for the recaps, u DB ladies are gold! Why wouldnt I want to love her when I started out that way?) The scenes are blurry because that's how Young sees the world now. Read More: Best Horror Movies of All Time. I was definitely perplexed, after having watched this episode. But Golden Wind was never meant to be about the best of society either. Hes clearly reluctant to go, and holds onto Youngs hand for as long as he can. Instead we only saw the aftermath in order to preserve the cheap surprise of finding out that Jin-sungs hand was the one holding the knife, but was anyone truly surprised? But no, Young frequently visited Soo's cafe, hears the bell on his bracelet and yet Soo doesn't reveal to her that it's him until much later. WHY WOULD YOU KILL HIM!? This is so poetic, lyrical, heart warming, exciting journey starts with the mythical story of Niamh and Oisin, continues with time changing moments of Irish Revolution and were catching glimpses from Michael Collins life story and his fight for freedom and finally witnessing an unconditional, timeless , amazing love story of Anne and Thomas. if (d.getElementById(id)) return; If it'd been left with Soo on a bicycle, then I'd have leaned towards him being dead. Even at the moment when I wanted to end it, a part of me still wanted you to run back to me. Learn more. It is a stunning work of fiction interwoven with true historical events, combining the magical and the real. She was slowly recovering her vision. this drama reminds me of eating cotton candy, while eating it, it is sweet and seems tangible, but when you are done you realize all that puff was mostly air. Ellie is an exceptionally angry teenager and is exceedingly cruel to her father. @picklemonster: That's actually pretty cool -- the not wanting to give false hope thing. Order our What the Wind Knows Study Guide. I mean, there's blunt force trauma, but it's not exactly subtle. Maybe this is how she sees redemption or growth. These 2 things really disappointed me, there were definetely some things who could have been done better, but on the other hand, im sure not many directors/writers could have succeded in making it better or at least as good as these producers did. i can't believe that is finished now.best best drama i have ever seem and it's the best drama of 2013. Shes happy to have Wang back. Several hints: the sad look on Jingsung's face even though he was with his family safe and sound; Young's long hair-there is no way a woman who just finished chemo could still have such long hair just six months out; there was this sadness through out the last few scenes-the falling flowers from the trees, the blurry and white-out treatment of the shots-some contributed to the theory she must have regained partial eyesight and that is why you see the blurry shots. For Vegas and victory. It had some surprises the biggest one that there was a happy ending. SPOILERS AHEAD. I will miss this drama.. hiks. One of the least enjoyable finales av ever watched! Even if she survives the stab wound from the scissors, which is bleeding profusely, she most likely slowly descends into madness before long. As folks already pointed out, I just don't get why Sec. He was timeless - simple, yet strong, and completely human. Please try your request again later. She is also haunted by Emma, who keeps asking Lizzy where her gun is. . I even watched the rerun on the weekends. The plot holes - oy! I glossed over a lot of the things a lot of people struggled with eg. Yes, the picture at the end was pretty. Hee-sun sees Soo off for his big gamble, after which he plans to go to the hospital to see Young. (And we don't know because we don't see anything alluding to that). Instead, our system considers things like how recent a review is and if the reviewer bought the item on Amazon. Outside the room, Sun-hee tells Soo that Moo-chul died after being sick for far too long. At least Moo-chuls minion seems to have Jin-sungs back. Maybe you can pretend her long hair is a wig, LOL. Just discovered him, and while I do agree he did well in A frozen flower, his movie that I loved him the most is A dirty carnival. Everything was so carefully built to that ending (except for the stabbing scene) that it felt planned to me. There were a lot of "wth" moments in the last few episodes that were left unresolved. Is art created by a computer an example of that computer's creativity? The one glaring weakness, for me, was the whole Jin-sung stabs Soo scene. I know what youre saying: Heads, thats crazy talk! Trust me, I know. After shes gone, Soo lets this news sink in. I Think the drama ended in happy ending. The last we see of Lizzy, she is injured but still alive. And yeah, if you compare the movie ending, there were no people around. The movie is theoretically open to two different interpretations, one in which there is a literal demon inhabiting the prairie and one in which the supernatural events of the film are largely happening in Lizzy's mind. She knows she is pregnant with Thomas's child, and she plans to remain in Ireland. By the time we reach its denouement . "But the wind and water know all the earth's secrets. They eventually decide on lambs ear, because that was the plant special to him and Young. It was LOST season six. Doctor Sun-hee treats Young at home, with Lawyer Jang and her closest friends watching nervously even as Sun-hee declares that Young will be fine when she wakes up. Because, it was so sweet but then it was so BLURRY! I for one liked the ending. it took 6 months for chemo and recovery. Neither of them died! Thank you Amy for this book, you are the most wonderful writer. She can write characters with extremely logical and complex psyche, even the baddies. (Just enough to pay Soos debt.) I don't see how the ending could be just a dream. A selection of scenes are shown, several with very little . At first, I thought it might be too boring (it's the opposite of TWTWB in terms of its lack of slickness and heightened intensity), and frankly, I couldn't imagine myself getting terribly invested in most of the characters. At times, I couldn't understand OY and I found her irritating sometimes. Sex isn't a shameful thing. Question: I know Heads explained it, however I am still confused, did OS kept folding because if he didn't win he would be dead (being killed by Boss Man) and Boss Man wouldn't be able to get his money back (and OS of course didn't know that Boss Man wanted him dead anyway, regardless of the results)? That is permanent and altered the scope of her life, but yet even at the end they are asking her to come back into Young's life. Depending on a viewer's experience the way the drama is seen will be different. You made viewing this beautiful drama (scenes, actors and soundtracks) even more memorable. Aka, back off. As far as stabbing goes guns are really hard to get in Korea so stabbing's the best way to kill someone. :3, Anyway, if that isn't enough to convince you, in an interview with Song Hye Gyo, she confirmed that it was a happy ending and both characters were alive. But, no matter what flaws this drama has, I have to admit that I do LOVE this drama. I don't think it was an excuse to put in alot of sex scenes. There was a time when I liked watching her because I expected things to change, and when they didnt, I couldnt understand why we would be expected to be on her journey no matter how much I wanted to be. She re-thought all her previous decisions from the night before and decided to watch the video Soo so wanted her to see, which told her nothing she didnt already realize internally. Get help and learn more about the design. Her secretly hoping that Oh Soo would burst in and save her makes sense (the only thing that made sense in this episode). I thought that you may not like me when you see me. When Young scoffs at this, he asks, Does that mean you like me?. In an even better play orchestrated by Jin-sung, Minion comes to the rescue as he and his men take over Boss Mans CCTV room so that they can keep watch over the game, ensuring that Boss Man cant cheat his way out AND to assure Jin-sung and Soos safe escape if they win. That ending just confused me. Whether it really hurt you as much as it hurt me when you were lying. I think that is what the writer ment. Zombie Young says okay, and he carries her three steps to the kitchen. Being along for the ride through Anne's perspective was everything I needed, while still getting to experience life through Thomas's eyes in his journal entries. Show! Isn't that what melos are (partially) made of- gut-wrenching decisions? version : 'v2.2' // use version 2.2 I did share and understood your (and others') frustrations of the characters. Thank you so much for the recap! : }); I cried like a baby. When I slit my wrist, I looked forward to you opening my door instead of feeling scared. By using our Services, you agree to our use of cookies. Because I could relate to Oh Young's character. Oh well. She got the call from Jin-sung while she was on her way to treat Young. Top subscription boxes right to your door, 1996-2023, Amazon.com, Inc. or its affiliates, Learn more how customers reviews work on Amazon. My first reaction to the ending was Soo is dead and all is in Young's head (because I'm a sucker for apparently, the traditional melodrama ending - I've been so out of it, I didn't know open ending or happy ending is an option!). 2,5, & 6 were my thoughts exactly. Thank you, Heads. I have all the reasons to have this drama, yet I love it and I enjoy it. Link's Awakening might not be as plot-heavy and narrative-driven as say a game like Breath of the Wild, but there are still some deep plot elements that make this game as memorable as anything else. It's a happy ending! Thank you so much Heads for your recaps. Theoretically, you have a beautiful setup with Jin Sung regarding Soo as his brother, as a part of his family, as the object of his loyalty and on the other side his commitment to his blood-related family and Hee Sun and Boss Kim in the background, pulling evil strings and digging his grave. Here's the guy who warned you again and again that Kim was bad news, to get out of Dodge ASAP and don't look back, who was always trying to get you out of the gangster life - and so you take the knife and leave the only true villain in the entire melo and go all the way out to the rooftop to stab your friend. Also, if they were both in the afterlife, I'm sure Young would get 100% of her sight back. He extorts a. that would be too much. Wang was forgiven so easily. With the help of an FBI officer (Jane Banner) and locals alike, the two try to uncover what seems to be a mysterious murder. The cinematography was imo not distracting but rather very well intergrated and instrumetalized, the music was good (this is where i usually loose my patience first) and Jo In Sung and Song Hye Gyo just clicked for melike massively, hugely, "pleaaase work together again". The beginning was wonderful, but it definitely lost steam and direction toward the end. I was captivated. Tracey Garvis Graves, New York Times bestselling author of On the Island and The Girl He Used to Know.