Thank you!! Hands down the best carnitas recipe! Hi, Im Holly! Checking everyone once in a while. I used the slower cooker method and then broiled to crisp it up. I got everything ready the night before & simply assembled it this morning. You can add coleslaw mix or salad if you desire. This looks unbelievably crisp and tender! Could I use caffeine free Coke? The flavor is so authentically Mexican. use it in a fried rice recipe for the meat. To reheat in the Oven (preferred): Preheat oven to 250F. Cooking for a larger party (roughly 20 people), would 6 pounds still be cooked 8-10 on low/5-6 on high? But using Dr. Pepper adds fruity, somewhat spiced notes to the pork that works so well with the BBQ sauce. Remove pork from crock pot and discard 97% of coke mixtureleaving just a little behind to help moisten the pork. Amazing! Transfer from slow cooker into a roasting pan (reserve liquid). To the remaining juices add salt and pepper to taste and a dash of Kitchen Bouquet. I would like to make it ahead of time for a party In 3 weeks. (This can be done the night before). My preferred method in to crisp on the stove in a frying pan with a little bit of olive oil. I cherish my kitchen and making delicious food for others. Trim the fat off the meat post-cooking. Thanks! The cookies is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Necessary". Luckily, I go back to Chicago a couple times a year to see my Dad and stepmom so I get as many of my fave restaurants in as possible. To Crisp in the Oven: Transfer the pork to a baking sheet lightly sprayed with cooking oil spray (or lined with aluminum foil or parchment paper). I do love pulled pork, though, and this recipe sounds wonderful! I did read a recipe that says to cube the pork, not sure if I will be doing this or not first. onto those mounds of cheese. 2) cilantro I think the question should be, what cant you do with leftover pulled pork? We have some left over for lunch. Ive made this recipe several times now to rave reviews every time! No huge mess with multiple pots and pans to clean afterwards. Im Kim. Yes this recipe was delightly AMAZING!! Woke up at 5:30 the next morning and set the cooker for 10 hours. I have a question from one of my roomates though, how would this recipe change without the garlic and onion? The flavours will be different each time and you may find you like some of them even more than the original! Ladle over about 1/2 cup of left over liquid, and continue cooking until the juices begin to reduce down and the meat is nice and crispy! Browning in oven (optional, recommended): Preheat oven to 180C / 350F. Cook on high for four to five hours (or low for eight). Does pulled pork need to be covered in liquid? For even more flavor, marinade the pork roast in the cola for up to 24 hours before cooking it. Is it normal for a daughter to hate her father? Who loves easy meals? Meanwhile, prepare Coca-Cola BBQ sauce by combining 2 cups Coca-Cola, ketchup, Worcestershire sauce, brown sugar, steak sauce, lemon juice, onion powder, remaining 1 teaspoon garlic powder and remaining 1 teaspoon black pepper in a bowl. What happens when you put Coca Cola in a crock pot? Check out my Slow Cooker Ropa Vieja, Crockpot Ham, and this Crockpot Pot Roast! Had a 8 lb.roast so tried both in the oven at 280 and crock pot. document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); This post may contain affiliate links. I am so glad that everyone enjoys it! Can I Make this Recipe in the Instant Pot? And so much easier than the other carnitas recipe I tried. I find if you cook it for the 8-10hrs slow cook then but it in a freezer bag and place it into the fridge for 3 days the flavour just absorbs really well into the meat and as the days progress as I had left overs its just taste more and more amazing! The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Other. I did 24lbs in 4 batches in the instant pot and it turned out great. Im currently making this, and my plan for my family of 3 is to half the 3lb pork shoulder before the browning step, and then freeze whole the remaining meat in the leftover defatted braising liquid. I followed the recipe to cook in oven covered for 3hrs at 300 and uncovered for 1-2 hrs and the pork came out dry not moist. That sounds great and delicious! I often just serve from the Crock-Pot with bbq sauce as pulled pork sandwiches! How is it done? Replace lid and continue baking. No votes so far! OMG this recipe nailed it for me. Thank you for the delish recipes and great inspiration. I'm Kim. Which is the most effective way to prevent viral foodborne illnesses? Rubbed that allover my roast and poured the liquid around the roast. These cookies help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc. For this most recent batch I have a 7lb bone-in shoulder, so I tweaked it a bit. I tried this for the first time today after reading all the glowing reviews. My husband loved it! Apple juice lacks the dark notes of cola. If I double the meat do I also have to double the cooking time in the crockpot? If you dont like the sound of this particular carnitas recipe, try my. Soda acts as great tenderizeryou could get a tender cut of meat grill-ready in less than a half-hour. I served these tacos at my bourbon tasting party and they were a big hit. Great seasoning, I wouldnt change a thing. Hey there! Only took 2 hours to make. Thank you so much! The pork will make more liquid as it cooks, and you need to leave room for that. Really appreciate your time and recipes . By clicking Accept All, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. This looks delish! Its one of our favorites! Cut the Cola: 10 Healthy (and Delicious) Soda Substitutes. Cover and cook on low heat setting for 8-10 hours, or high heat for 5-6 hours (until the meat falls apart). 5 lb. I cant wait to try it for dinner tonight! My husband and I will be backwoods camping out west, and because of heavy forest fires, there is a burn ban (no campfires). Check that the pork has reached an internal temperature of at least 195 degrees F/90 degrees C before carefully lifting out and onto a cutting board. Do you think it should be crisped on the day after of or before freezing? That is great to hear! Thank you so much for sharing! So you would need (2) 5lb pork cooking in 2 different crackpots. Next, we rub the roast with a bunch of southern spices such as paprika, creole seasoning, garlic powder and black pepper. I made this exactly as written and it was phenomenal!!! . Have now made this three times and had to write and rave about it.. Couldnt be easier or tastier and it made the kitchen smell great! That will add more flavor! This recipe couldnt get much better..its definitely restaurant quality. I followed the recipe to the letter, choosing to fresh squeeze the lime and oranges (I used Blood oranges which were AWESOME). TFTR! The meat was fall off bone tender 8 hours later. This was delicious! Thank you so much. One pound of pulled pork will feed approximately 3 people (about 5 ounces per serving). If you are hosting friends for a weekend catch-up or to watch the football on tv, there couldnt be a more perfect recipe! Thanks. Yes, you can cook this in the over in a Dutch oven if you have one, at 350F. Great recipe; have made it several times. Thanks, this is now at least a twice a month meal! Remove bones and discard. 7) crumbled cotija cheese Im trying this tonight. I am making this tomorrow for Patriots Game in Dutch Oven as well and then removing lid for the crisping of it. Amazing. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. If you have a 600ml bottle, this will be just over half your bottle and makes it easy to estimate without measuring. Decided to cook the whole thing using my portable roaster oven, and Im sure it will be great. My husband says its as good as the mexican restaurant down the street (southern california so its the real deal lol). Use an electric mixer! Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. I actually used a 6 lb bone-in pork butt.the meat fell off the bone, and I agree- the key to this recipe is the Mexican Coke. Are you married ? The orange juice and lime juice combo tenderises them to incredible fall apart tenderness, while the natural sugars in the juices and the coke combined turn what would be just another pulled pork recipe, into crispy heaven with every mouthful. Hi Jo. Serve this for dinner with a piece of banana pudding poke cake for dessert, and your family will be thrilled! It did not disappoint. I am so surprised a crockpot pulled this off. BBQ Sauce Combine all ingredients in a saucepan. Functional cookies help to perform certain functionalities like sharing the content of the website on social media platforms, collect feedbacks, and other third-party features. So took longer in my slow cooker, about 10 hrs. Remove lid and cook for an additional 1-2 hours, until pork is tender and easily pulls apart with a fork. I am going to try an make this recipe this weekend, it sounds so good. What can I use in place of beer for pulled pork? Pour 1 ladle full (about 1 cup) of the liquid from the slow cooker over the pork to season. Excellent, traditional tasting recipe, and does it all without the mess of lard! The limes and oranges, along with my frozen roast, created plenty of juices. It was hands down the best carnitas I have ever made and had. There are so many different types of pulled pork and sauces, from tomato based sauce to sauces with a vinegar base, to put on the pork. Yep! Followed recipe exactly today. You can also use the bread to sop up all that excess sauce on your plate! I will try this recipe with Oxtails as it is a specialty dish in my home country of Belize. THESE WERE AMAZING!! Use whichever soda you have on hand! Probably favorite online recipe of all time. If I dont have a slow cooker, can you make this in the oven? Next up is another classic coleslaw. I read, researched, tested, failed, tested again, failed, researched AGAIN, tested and failed THREEmore times. I used an 8 lb pork picnic (shoulder with bone) so it fit into my 6 qt slow cooker. Plastic bag, or container, with or without juice? Remove the pork from the brine and pat dry. If you happen to have any leftovers, there are so many ways you can use them up. Mix in Coca-Cola BBQ sauce. BBQ pulled pork is a great recipe to have up your sleeve because you can do a whole lot more with it than just add it to rolls. It took a lot longer than 10 minutes to get the results I like. 5) pickled onions My go to, but this time Im going to try the other one with tomatoes. Remove any bones and trim all fat. ADDED INGREDIENT: I browned a tiny bit of tomato paste with the onions for another 90 seconds. What an amazing recipe. Delicious! Thanks for posting. Or make your own loaded nachos or fries by topping with your slow-cooked pulled pork, salsa, cheese, sour cream and guacamole. If you are going for the bread roll or bread option, add coleslaw on top for that American cuisine inspired flavour. Enjoy XO. Instructions. Not sure where you are in Florida but if you are anywhere near my area head over to Goldrush BBQ in Venice they serve a delicious BBQ beef brisket! This will provide the moistest result for your pulled pork. Do I have to take it out of the liquid when storing it or can it be left in it? I have not tried it in an instant pot. I just made this recipe using Venison and it worked great and tasted amazing! Definitely will be making these again! I made this again today (Feb. 3rd, 2019) With all of the ingredients and it came out AMAZING!. Gotta admit it was the first time I had had carnitas, and, I was in LOVE with his!! Stir until it comes to a boil. Youre our favorite food blogger and recipe creator. I was so nervous about using the coke, but I figured worst case we can just make something else. Heres a hack for ya: pour some of the Coke into the bottle and give it a good shake. Pulled pork also tastes great on its own, served with salad or vegetables instead. I made nearly 8 lbs of this for about 20 guests for our Cinco de Mayo party and it was ALL GONE. . However, I do have to admit, I find it gets a little more tender when its slow cooked all day in the crockpot instead. boneless pork butt or shoulder roast, 1/2 white or yellow onion, finely chopped. Your recipe for the bbq sauce was a hit! You want them warm and soft, not crispy and tough. The only differences were I used Badia Naranja Agria and Cherry Pepsi, because thats what I had. Alternatively, substitute with chicken broth (chicken stock). Great recipe! Once you have the ingredients, its as easy as putting it in the slow cooker and waiting. Also, be sure to give the shoulder or butt a healthy rub and then braise the meat in a cast iron skillet before slow cooking. I even drank the while the carnitas were browning. (Made Street Tacos) My first comment didnt read correctly. Sad fact! I love new delicious recipes. Serve and enjoy. Id really appreciate the feed back! It was fantastic! We eat Mexican food almost daily and this is the best carnitas Ive ever made. To slow-cook, place the pork shoulder in a Dutch oven or another heavy pot, then pour enough broth, beer, or other liquid to partially submerge the meat. This cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. One, I marinated the pork butt in all the ingredients overnight and my husband cooked it low and slow on the smoker the next day. This way, I get some pieces that are a little bigger along with the shreds. Hes alergic, and wondered if it would stay relativly the same, og change dramaticly. Pour over more of the slow cooker juices once the meat has crisped for added flavour, just before serving! Tag me at @simplifycreateinspire on Instagram. This Coca Cola pulled pork recipe is perfect for summer barbecues, or for cozy winter nights at home! The whole family loved it and I suspect it will become a tradition. So happy to have found this! What kind of wood did you use for smoking? Flipped it half way through. With a bone in Pork Butt as well.